Saturday, November 7, 2009

I was at Thursday's House Call on Congress...

...and the questions I keep being asked are 1)Why did you go? 2)What did you see?

Why I went

Last night, in an Saturday-night-session, the US House of Representatives passed their health care reform bill. So, it could be argued that the rally failed.

But the reason I went was voiced best by Ronald Reagan, "Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn't pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same, or one day we will spend our sunset years telling our children and our children's children what it was once like in the United States where men were free."

If that sad day comes, I don't want to have to tell my children and grandchildren that I did nothing when our country became socialist.

Some may feel that this is an over-reaction. Surely the United States is not going socialist just because of a health care reform bill... right?

This bill will give us a "public option." The public option gives us socialized medicine. Socialized medicine - which is 1/6th of the total economy - will give us socialism generally. Once the Senate passes it and the President signs it, the clock will be ticking. I'd give it 10 years. Optimistically.

How will it happen? The President keeps referring to the entrance of the government into the private insurance market as increased competition. Wrong. The government doesn't compete when it enters a market. It doesn't have to worry about little things like profit or debt or cost. The public option will undercut the private insurance companies. They will abandon the field to the government. The public option will become the only option.

Sounding so magnanimous, the President keeps saying that if you want to keep your private insurance, you will be allowed to. Thank you Mr. President. If I raise my hand will I be allowed to go to the restroom too? That sounds pretty bitter, but as written this health care bill would not allow you to change any aspect of your coverage - you can't or you lose it. The theory I guess is that if you're unhappy with the coverage that you bought 5 years ago, then you need the government.

Once we're all on the public option they have us. There will be no liberal or conservative battles anymore. Its over. The liberals will have won. The center of political gravity will have moved to issues like - how many heart transplants are we going to pay for this year?

Health is one of the two big paths to socialism. What you buy at the grocery store, the house you live in, the job you do: all touch on your health. Once your health is the government's business, they can control you.

The other path to socialism, by the way, is the environment. Every aspect of your life including the CO2 you exhale touches on the environment. I believe that its no coincidence that this government is working on "health care reform" and "cap and trade" simultaneously. They are two vehicles taking us to the same place.

The other thing that I and many in the crowd protested was the use of public dollars funding elective abortions. The Democrats promised it wouldn't be in there, but (like the promise to publicly post the bill for 72 hours before the vote) it was a lie. Its in there.

What I saw



If you click on the image above you can see a larger version of the Google map of capitol hill. I got off the metro (the DC subway) at the Capitol South Station located at the bottom right of the picture. It's marked with a number "1." As I exited the station I saw anti-abortion protesters going up the 1st Street Southeast. I walked west on Independence Avenue and then walked around the East side of the Capitol taking a quick detour to see the U.S. Supreme Court. Then I walked around to the west side of the Capitol.

It is a beautiful place. The yard is part of a national botanical garden. Behind us was the Grant Memorial and the Washington Monument.

People were just beginning to gather at 10:00 am when I showed up. These people have been called astro-turf - a fake grass-roots uprising sponsored by health insurance companies and other vested interests. And, in a remarkable contradiction of that first point, they've been referred to as ugly and disorganized. One wonders what level of organization would not be either astro-turf or angry mob in they eyes of those critics.

The truth is that these were ordinary people:



Some young.



Some not so young.



Some had funny outfits and hand written signs like this guy.



Or had banners like this conservative answer to ACORN.



There were more than a few Gadsden Flags.



But most of us were standing there empty-handed yelling "NO" to an out-of-control government.



Conservatively there were 8,000 to 10,000 people there. I thought I read a Fox News estimate of 20,000 people, but I can't find it now. I don't doubt the 20,000 number. The entire area I sprayed orange on the Google map picture was full with people standing shoulder-to-shoulder.

This was Minnesota Representative Michele Bachmann's idea. She started the event welcoming us all. We prayed, said the pledge of allegiance emphasizing "under God" because "it drives liberals crazy." And then Bachmann introduced actor Jon Voight.



Mr. Voight asked of Obama "Could it be he has had 20 years of subconscious programming by Reverend Wright to damn America?"

A copy of the huge bill was lampooned throughout the afternoon. "What the hell is this?" asked Mark Levine as he stepped to the podium. Levine is author of the awesome book "Liberty and Tyranny" that's serving as a guidebook for many tea party folks.



One height-challenged speaker threw the bill to the stage and stood on top of it to see the back of the crowd, "There you are!" he said, "Hey, this bill is good for something after all."

Let me address one stupid comment made about the event by The Washington Post:

a man standing just beyond the TV cameras apparently suffered a heart attack 20 minutes after event began. Medical personnel from the Capitol physician's office -- an entity that could, quite accurately, be labeled government-run health care -- rushed over, attaching electrodes to his chest and giving him oxygen and an IV drip.

This turned into an unwanted visual for the speakers, as a D.C. ambulance and firetruck, lights flashing, pulled in just behind the lawmakers.


First, I did not detect even a hesitation in the program when this happened. I would guess that anytime you get a group of thousands of emotionally charged citizens together, you are going to have a heart episode or two. The speakers took it in stride. Second, how exactly does one guy falling out and somebody calling him an ambulance undercut the argument against socialized medicine?

I'm glad that I didn't buy a sandwich at the Capitol snack bar. By the Washington Post's logic I'd be sending the message that we need Soviet-style state farms and food distribution lines.

As I was leaving Capitol Hill I saw a couple of people arrested in the middle of the intersection of 1st Street Southeast and Independence Avenue. One observer standing next to me made an angry call to his congressman saying "they were arrested for praying." Well, no. They were arrested for blocking the street... while praying. I suspect that being arrested was part of their plan.

So there was some mild civil disobedience, but that was the exception. Most of these people were law-and-order types. One liberal blogger made fun of this group for not jay-walking. Yeah, so? We also didn't leave Capitol Hill littered like after a typical lefty protest.

This is one reason why lawmakers and liberal commentators are going to miss the significance of the tea parties. These aren't jobless (yet) never-do-wells that protest because they don't have any responsibilities. These are good people that took time off, got a sitter for the kids, and came, usually, at their own expense. They spend their lives following the rules, being productive, and raising kids.

For every one of us that came, there are 1000 that couldn't come who feel the same and support our protest. These tea parties are the tip of an iceberg that this Congress is ignoring at its political peril.

12 comments:

  1. Thanks for this report and for representing those of us who couldn't make it. I was there for the 9-12 march and will go back if there's another rally prior to the Senate vote (which there should be). Something everyone can do is start organizing at the local level in preparation for the elections. I've worked alongside conservatives before. We're a determined bunch and we will prevail.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I couldn't come.

    Instead I was with the 150+ people who went to our representative's office here in NC at the same time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ditto. I was there and posted about a conversation I overheard on the train. See my blog at http://ibdst.blogspot.com. Curiously I have yet to see a photo of the whole crowd from the perspective of the Capital...

    ReplyDelete
  4. I hope you are right about the numbers. There seems to be a large support for this health care and other govt interventions (ie cap & trade). Losing in NY-23 did not give me confidence that even an inspired conservative run could win. I think we may truly be lost. It is a sad time for America

    ReplyDelete
  5. Pragmatist? Hardly.

    How the anti-abortion crowd gave us socialized medicine.

    You can take comfort in the fact that there is no Federal Funding of abortion in the bill.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Beautiful post and pics! We were there and it was EXACTLY as you say. I have shared your post with all my FB friends.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Peg:

    I can't take credit for all the photos. I wasn't close enough to the podium to get those great shots of the speakers. That pic of Jon Voight is an AP photo. The pic showing the bill is from CBN I believe.

    It was a great day to be with Patriots regardless of the Saturday sneak. Now its time to oppose the senate vote.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I estimated 15,000- 20,000 since there were people to the right of the area in front of the west steps. I was there with my DONT TREAD ON ME Navy Jack.

    I was told by people who tried to enter the Capitol that they could not do so and on the east side the Capitol police were at the top of the steps with automatic weapons. The person who told me that was shocked that they were carrying automatic weapons. That is not unusual in Mexico, or even Germany and Britain, but not so normal in the US even after the terrorist attacks. I guess Pelosi is afraid of the people. There were rumors that Pelosi would have us removed from the Capitol grounds, but I didn't think even she was that stupid. Had that happened, I was fully prepared to shout for a sit-in in the honorable tradition of MLK.
    During the February 27, 2009 first DC TEA Party we were observed by at least one Federal SWAT member at Lafayette Park. He said that was normal for protests, however he was not carrying an automatic weapon.

    There was a protest and the shining of flashlights on the MD public provided residence of our tax increasing governor in August to symbolically shine the light on government. I couldn't make the protest but I was told the governor called the police and the 500 or so demonstrators were given 15 minutes to disperse or they would be arrested. The citizens left as ordered, but had I been there I would have called for a sit-down and forced us to be arrested. But as usual the good citizens obeyed the order and guess what, I saw no coverage of the event. I have been to 16 TEA Parties and they have been orderly and respectful of the authorities and property, yet our representatives to a large extent have ignored us and passed national healthcare with unconstitutional mandates that restrict our economic freedom and civil liberties; those that our forefathers fought a revolution over and MLK died to ensure all American's constitutional rights were honored. Our present congress and administration don't seem to feel the need to honor those sacrifices and uphold their oaths of office!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I've heard a lot of stuff about how socialized medicine leads to socialism in general. And I think there's some truth in that. It's basically a big jumpstart along Hayek's Road to Serfdom.

    But it doesn't have to be like that. I say this not to support health care reform - I'm opposed to it - but so that people do not lose heart if it is passed.

    Canada has socialized health care. And it did lead to some further encroachments into the private sphere by the government in the name of 'public health'. But even with socialized medicine, government is shrinking in Canada, and has been shrinking for the last ten years. Canadians have walked back the size of government from almost 50% of GDP to less than 40%, and by this time next year Canada's government will be smaller than the U.S. government in terms of GDP. Canada is also lowering business taxes and until recently was running budget surpluses. Finally, Canada is also in the process of re-introducing private health care into the public system.

    Public health care can be the wedge which takes a country towards socialism - or it can be the socialist example of how bad the government really is at running everything. If it consumes all the political oxygen in the room, there may not be much left for further experiments in government.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I saw the abortion amendment vote, followed by the final vote, followed by Nancy Pelosi's Cheshire Cat imitation.

    Now I know why I feel like Alice, but it ain't no wonderland.

    ReplyDelete
  11. M. Simon:

    Yes, abortion was taken out at the last minute.

    I'm not sure how many votes that swung, but that's hardly the only reason I or other people were out there protesting.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Good summation in the "why I was there" section, but the bill that passed is even worse than you said when it comes to "keeping your own plan if you like it". I wrote about some details here: http://increasinglyuncommoncommonsense.blogspot.com/2009/11/book-em-dano.html

    I had planned to be there, but my appointment that morning in the DC suburbs canceled and I suddenly was responsible for watching my children so...I missed it. I was at the 9/12 rally and will be at the next one. Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete